TheReference

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Friday, October 5, 2012

Sheldon Glashow: Does science evolve through blind chance or Intelligent Design?

Posted on 7:32 AM by Unknown
Five months ago or so, Honeywell organized a series of lectures by the Nobel laureate Sheldon Glashow at the Czech Technical University (ČVUT) in Prague.

The lecture you can watch now asked the question whether science evolves by chance or by design.



It's a sort of a fun, light, philosophically and historically loaded talk.




Maybe the number of the historical episodes will be boring for you: he could be a professional historian of science right away.



Typical Czech engineering students are listening to Glashow. ;-)

But if you like the first part, continue with Part 2 and Part 3. If you make it to the third part, there will be some examples of his point from modern physics. Around 18:00, he also talks about Gell-Mann and quarks' and string theorists' delight when they deduced that string theory predicted gravity. Glashow doesn't count it as a prediction because he had known about gravity before string theory was born. Of course, from the viewpoint of the history of science, it wasn't a (new) prediction: the chronology guarantees that. However, from the viewpoint of science and the strength and validity of its hypotheses, the fact that string theory implies general relativity is exactly as important and consequential as a prediction! The chronology is just a part of the history, social science, it was accidental, and a scientist simply can't pay attention to such things.

On the other hand, I agree that both accidental discoveries as well as "planned research" have been important and will be important.



Some other not-too-demanding physics news: Australia opened the world's fastest radio telescope.

Robert Christy, a physicist who worked on the Manhattan Project and the first one who became hostile against Edward Teller after he identified Oppenheimer as a communist, died.



An 11-year-old maľchik (=Russian boy) discovered the mammoth of the century (the best preserved one in 100 years).
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in philosophy of science, science and society, video | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Ostragene: realtime evolution in a dirty city
    Ostrava , an industrial hub in the Northeast of the Czech Republic, is the country's third largest city (300,000). It's full of coal...
  • Likely: latest Atlantic hurricane-free date at least since 1941
    Originally posted on September 4th. Now, 5 days later, it seems that no currently active systems will grow to a hurricane so the records wi...
  • Origin of the name Motl
    When I was a baby, my father would often say that we come a French aristocratic dynasty de Motl – for some time, I tended to buy it ;-). Muc...
  • Papers on the ER-EPR correspondence
    This new, standardized, elegant enough name of the Maldacena-Susskind proposal that I used in the title already exceeds the price of this b...
  • Bernhard Riemann: an anniversary
    Georg Friedrich Bernhard Riemann was born in a village in the Kingdom of Hanover on September 17th, 1826 and died in Selasca (Verbania), No...
  • New iPhone likely to have a fingerprint scanner
    One year ago, Apple bought AuthenTec , a Prague-based security company ( 7 Husinecká Street ), for $356 million. One may now check the Czech...
  • Prediction isn't the right method to learn about the past
    Happy New Year 2013 = 33 * 61! The last day of the year is a natural moment for a blog entry about time. At various moments, I wanted to wri...
  • Lubošification of Scott Aaronson is underway
    In 2006, quantum computing guy Scott Aaronson declared that he was ready to write and defend any piece of nonsensical claim about quantum gr...
  • A slower speed of light: MIT relativistic action game
    In the past, this blog focused on relativistic optical effects and visualizations of Einstein's theory: special relativity (download Re...
  • Eric Weinstein's invisible theory of nothing
    On Friday, I received an irritated message from Mel B. who had read articles in the Guardian claiming that Eric Weinstein found a theory of ...

Categories

  • alternative physics (7)
  • astronomy (49)
  • biology (19)
  • cars (2)
  • climate (93)
  • colloquium (1)
  • computers (18)
  • Czechoslovakia (57)
  • Denmark (1)
  • education (7)
  • Europe (33)
  • everyday life (16)
  • experiments (83)
  • France (5)
  • freedom vs PC (11)
  • fusion (3)
  • games (2)
  • geology (5)
  • guest (6)
  • heliophysics (2)
  • IQ (1)
  • Kyoto (5)
  • landscape (9)
  • LHC (40)
  • markets (40)
  • mathematics (37)
  • Middle East (12)
  • missile (9)
  • murders (4)
  • music (3)
  • philosophy of science (73)
  • politics (98)
  • religion (10)
  • Russia (5)
  • science and society (217)
  • sports (5)
  • string vacua and phenomenology (114)
  • stringy quantum gravity (90)
  • TBBT (5)
  • textbooks (2)
  • TV (8)
  • video (22)
  • weather records (30)

Blog Archive

  • ►  2013 (341)
    • ►  September (14)
    • ►  August (42)
    • ►  July (36)
    • ►  June (39)
    • ►  May (38)
    • ►  April (41)
    • ►  March (44)
    • ►  February (41)
    • ►  January (46)
  • ▼  2012 (159)
    • ►  December (37)
    • ►  November (50)
    • ▼  October (53)
      • CMS proton-lead ridge: color glass condensate?
      • Was Sandy systemically caused by CO2?
      • Different ways to interpret Feynman diagrams
      • Is Hurricane Sandy unprecedented?
      • Doha, Qatar will host a climate conference
      • Preons probably can't exist
      • Galileo's 1633 trial: a tragic hero
      • Anniversaries: Meitner, van Vleck, Mills, Bohm
      • The holographic principle
      • Evangelista Torricelli: an anniversary
      • PBS Frontline: Climate of Doubt
      • Czech police uncovers a $20 million carbon credit ...
      • Candida: uncertainties, strategies, victories
      • Climate hysteria in presidential debates RIP (1988...
      • Alan Guth on himself, science, cosmology
      • Edward Witten on science, strings, himself
      • Italy earthquake witch trial: 6 years in prison
      • In awe about entanglement
      • Livescribe Smartpen
      • How empty is the black hole interior?
      • Raphael Bousso converts to the Church of Firewall
      • Czech PM ready to veto EU bank supervision
      • Steven Weinberg will not vote for Obama
      • Enthusiasm about the economics Nobel prize: Roth a...
      • Planet with 4 stars found by armchairs astronomers
      • Classification of simple compact Lie groups
      • HadCRUT4: no warming for 16 years
      • Chemists' name for honesty: testosterone
      • Czech regional elections: Pilsen defends some decency
      • EU: a Nobel Peace Prize?
      • Classical physics is sometimes more indeterministi...
      • The Higgs boson observation: Sheldon hires a hottie
      • Kevin Trenberth: too bureaucratic IPCC sucks
      • DNA not long-lived, Jurassic Park claimed unlikely
      • Earth may be cancelling the 2012-2013 El Niño
      • Spread SUSY: wino LSP, displaced vertices, cosmic ...
      • Physics Nobel prize: Haroche and Wineland
      • Supergod challenge: proving a $300 inequality
      • Symbolab: search engine for equations in LaTeX
      • Bohr-Einstein debates: 8 decades later
      • ATLAS: some small multijet excesses
      • Electron's electric quadrupole moment
      • Climate sensitivities in various papers
      • Sheldon Glashow: Does science evolve through blind...
      • Václav Havel Airport Prague: the new name
      • Obama schooled by Romney: why he has no passion
      • Evading quantum mechanics: again
      • SUSY with a colored adjoint chiral multiplet
      • EU bureaucrats' new strategy to close Czech nuclea...
      • Miracles prove the divine power of string theory
      • Higgs: living near the cliff of instability
      • Harvard's divestments: Israel and fossil fuels
      • Nima Arkani-Hamed attracts India to physics
    • ►  September (19)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile